The devil owns tomorrow/
And yesterday as well./
He weaves them both together/
To make a place called Hell./
Tomorrow's free from sorrow/
And yesterday's regret./
But it's Hell to wait for all these years/
When tomorrow's not here yet.
Monday, July 27, 2009
Sunday, July 19, 2009
Retribution: They Deserve It!

Retribution:
The most common basis for support of the death penalty is retribution. There are two formulations of the retribution case: 1) the punishment fits the crime and 2) the criminal deserves the punishment. A 2003 poll reported that 37% of death penalty supporters endorse the first and 13% cite the second. [Presumably, this case is based on the assumption that the system can actually identify who deserves it with an acceptable degree of legal and social certainty, a proposition under siege as the list of Death Row exonerations grows. New Mexico Governor Bill Richardson said he supports the death penalty and that some people deserve it but since he can’t be sure who they are, he signed a bill abolishing it in 2009.]
Since the resumption of capital punishment in 1976, 1170 people have been executed. Are we to believe this is the entire universe of those ‘who deserved it’?
That not all who deserve it get it supports an unfavorable inference that the selection process is driven by something other than high principles of retributive justice.
What’s fair in theory may be foul in practice.
Whether the reason for selective application of capital punishment is an accident of geography or a studied application of the fine art of plea-bargaining or jury nullification or a sad fortuity of mitigating factors present in the background of one shooter but not the other, the result is the same: application of retributive justice is capricious, governed by the same laws that govern where lightening will strike, who it will hit and who, if anyone, it will kill.
This is bad constitutional law and worse public policy.
Labels:
death penalty,
executions,
lethal injection,
retributio
Wednesday, July 1, 2009
Tuesday, June 16, 2009
The Tree of Knowledge
Truth is fit enough for prose/It tells use everything it knows
But knowledge is its own disguise/Using truth to tell us lies.
Sunday, June 7, 2009
The Death Reward
The Death Reward
From criminal law, we know the death penalty as a deterrent to crime and the ultimate punishment given only to those who deserve it. But from the Guantanamo Bay Detention Camp we have discovered something new: the Death Reward.
According to the New York Times, various prisoners at the Camp want to confess and be executed now so they can reap the rewards of martyrdom.
So for one person execution is a punishment, for another a reward. Execution deters one, and allures another. More evidence that the death penalty is really simply maddness.
From criminal law, we know the death penalty as a deterrent to crime and the ultimate punishment given only to those who deserve it. But from the Guantanamo Bay Detention Camp we have discovered something new: the Death Reward.According to the New York Times, various prisoners at the Camp want to confess and be executed now so they can reap the rewards of martyrdom.
So for one person execution is a punishment, for another a reward. Execution deters one, and allures another. More evidence that the death penalty is really simply maddness.
Labels:
death award,
death penalty,
death reward,
Guantanamo,
martyrdom
Sunday, May 31, 2009
Idleness: Melancholy's Greatest Cause (and Symptom)
Idleness & Melancholy
Burton cites idleness as both a symptom and cause of melancholy and enlists the authority of Rhasis, Plutarch, Homer, Montaltus and Mercurialis who account idleness as melancholy's greatest cause. Here is Burton's description of idleness written in 1628:
"…. idleness (the badge of gentry), the bane of body and mind, the nurse of naughtiness, step mother of discipline, the chief author of all mischief, one of the seven deadly sins, and the sole cause of this [melancholy] and many other maladies, the devil's cushion...his pillow and chief reposal.... Nothing begets it [melancholy] sooner, increaseth and continueth it oftener, than idleness; a disease [melancholy] familiar to all idle persons, an inseparable companion to such as live at ease, a life out of action, and have no calling or ordinary employment to busy themselves…As fern grows in untilled grounds, and all manner of weed, so do gross humours in an idle body….An idle dog will be mangy….wit without employment is a disease, the rust of the soul, a plague, a hell itself, the greatest danger of the soul.”
---Robert Burton, The Anatomy of Melancholy (with the Latin completely given in translation and embodied in an All-English text), edited by Floyd Dell and Paul Jordan-Smith, Tudor Publishing Company, New York, MCMXLVVIII pages 210-213.
Burton cites idleness as both a symptom and cause of melancholy and enlists the authority of Rhasis, Plutarch, Homer, Montaltus and Mercurialis who account idleness as melancholy's greatest cause. Here is Burton's description of idleness written in 1628:"…. idleness (the badge of gentry), the bane of body and mind, the nurse of naughtiness, step mother of discipline, the chief author of all mischief, one of the seven deadly sins, and the sole cause of this [melancholy] and many other maladies, the devil's cushion...his pillow and chief reposal.... Nothing begets it [melancholy] sooner, increaseth and continueth it oftener, than idleness; a disease [melancholy] familiar to all idle persons, an inseparable companion to such as live at ease, a life out of action, and have no calling or ordinary employment to busy themselves…As fern grows in untilled grounds, and all manner of weed, so do gross humours in an idle body….An idle dog will be mangy….wit without employment is a disease, the rust of the soul, a plague, a hell itself, the greatest danger of the soul.”
---Robert Burton, The Anatomy of Melancholy (with the Latin completely given in translation and embodied in an All-English text), edited by Floyd Dell and Paul Jordan-Smith, Tudor Publishing Company, New York, MCMXLVVIII pages 210-213.
Labels:
Homer,
idlenss,
melancholy,
Montaltus,
Plutarch,
Rhasis,
Robert Burton
Monday, May 25, 2009
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
.jpg)
